Court Bans In-Office Judge Romance
Switzerland’s highest judicial body has ruled that romantic relationships between federal judges are incompatible with the court’s professional standards and judicial customs.
The decision was made during an extraordinary meeting of all members of the Federal Supreme Court of Switzerland on Wednesday following public attention surrounding a relationship between two federal judges.
The controversy emerged after reports revealed a relationship between federal judge Beatrice van de Graaf and federal judge Yves Donzallaz. The matter became public in April through reporting by the German-language publication Weltwoche.
According to a statement released by the Federal Court, judges are expected to avoid behaviour that could raise concerns about their independence, impartiality, or the reputation of the judiciary.
The court announced that an independent panel of experts will examine the specific case involving the two judges. An external specialist has been tasked with clarifying the facts and reporting findings to the Administrative Commission of the Federal Court.
Officials stated that the investigation results are expected by the end of June, after which the court will decide on any further action.
While the inquiry into the individual case remains ongoing, the court separately confirmed that romantic relationships between members of the court are fundamentally considered incompatible with current judicial conduct standards.
The development has sparked debate in Switzerland regarding judicial ethics, independence, and personal conduct within the country’s highest legal institutions.

